Public Humiliation

by Lisa Rosen on January 7, 2010

Remember back before Christmas,when I posted a list of interesting fitness-themed gift ideas?  One of the things on the list was the Withings internet-connected body scale.

Well, ours arrived day before yesterday.

Yes, we now own a scale that keeps an online record of my weight and body-fat percentage.  It will even post the results to Twitter.  The prospect is  . . . horrifying.  But oddly compelling.

Let me just get the public humiliation part of this over with:  I’ve gained 17 pounds in the last two years.  Yes, I know–I write a blog all about staying fit and eating carefully and watching your weight.  I should practice what I preach, and I’m embarrassed to admit that I obviously don’t.  Actually, if I’m totally honest, I’ve gained 20 pounds, but that was over a longer period of time–I weighed 123 pounds back in 2003, for a few months.  I was training hard.  At least when it slipped back up to 126 my clothes didn’t stop fitting.  Now?  Let’s just say my wardrobe is limited to stretchy waistbands at this point.  It’s time to get back to a sensible weight.  Starting today.

So, now we have this scale.  It’s not all that different from the scale we had before–our old Tanita did a body-fat reading as well as a weight measurement, so I’m not getting any data that I didn’t already have.  Which makes me wonder why this new scale seems more interesting.  Thus far, what we have is a fairly attractive new toy that keeps a computerized record so we don’t have to write anything down.  I haven’t yet set up my account to tweet my read-outs (although I probably will, because apparently I have some sort of perverse social death wish).

What you see in the graphic above is what happened when I stepped on the scale this morning.  Ugh.

I think it’s the automatic record-keeping that appeals to me.  Lee has always been in the habit (and by always I mean for the last eleven years) of writing down his weight and body-fat, so that he can see trends before they get out of hand.  I don’t do that; I’ve never been that organized.  I’m also really good at convincing myself that today’s 1/2 pound gain “doesn’t count” because of the salt in last night’s soy sauce, or because I’m PMS-ing, or because yesterday’s weight lifting is making my muscles bigger already (riiiiight).

I know all this sounds like I’m advocating obsessing over details, and I know I usually talk about balance and perspective and lifestyle vs. diet and all that, but over time, it’s the details that add up to the big picture.  I think that by not forcing myself to pay attention to the details every day, I was able to ignore (maybe deny would be a better word) the trend that was right there on my bathroom scale.

So now I’m putting the trend out there for the world to see.  I hope that having the visual–the graph that shows me the picture of my day-to-day progress–will be enough to keep me motivated.  If it’s not, I’m going to need you, my dear readers (all three of you–there are three of you reading, right?) to give me a swift kick in the pants.

Public humiliation, indeed.

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }

catherine pate January 7, 2010 at 9:17 pm

i used to SWEAR i would never, ever step on a scale on again. i wouldn’t be controlled by it. however, being in a much healthier, less neurotic (about food that it) place, i totally get why this is useful. the numbers are not evil– it just is what it is. and your need to just put all this info. out there is the very same reason i am a totally social exerciser. i used people as a crutch when i am not feeling motivated to run. i borrow some of their energy, and share mine when my running buddy needs a boost. i won’t give you a kick in the pants, but i will give you a pat on the back for not giving up! :)
great post.

rebyj January 8, 2010 at 2:08 pm

What a nifty gadget! Good luck, you can do it, just move around more.Which means use an ipod touch or phone to tweet with so you can walk and twitter at same time! (Yes, I am brilliant)

Lala Yu January 8, 2010 at 6:03 pm

This is the most perverse invention yet, in terms of social media. I’m all at once intrigued and repulsed by the idea of buying one. Or I’m going to come over & use yours. And then pretend the details on your progress are mine. Great post.

Trevor Burnette January 9, 2010 at 3:00 pm

Lisa I feel your pain… I weighed 180 just a few years ago and now I’m pushing 205. How’s a guy to lose weight when Whopper Jrs are only a dollar!

Lisa Rosen January 10, 2010 at 1:25 pm

Thanks, Catherine–you nailed it. The numbers are neutral INFORMATION. So hard to separate the emotional baggage from the data. (& so easy to think the scale has malicious intentions!)

Lisa Rosen January 10, 2010 at 1:29 pm

Oh, Reby–you’re definitely brilliant! I always take my blackberry with me on a walk (now if this ridiculous cold snap would end, I could actually GO for a walk).
Thanks for reading!

Lisa Rosen January 10, 2010 at 1:33 pm

Lala–I agree–it is perverse, but also oddly compelling. And yes, Toby’s evil-prankster persona woke up the minute he realized the potential for havoc.

Lisa Rosen January 10, 2010 at 1:34 pm

Hi Trevor–
It’s so hard! I. Love. Food. I just have to remind myself, every day, that I love my health, too.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: